When Should Monitoring Reopen Watershed Protection?
By Özge Çelik Yılmaz

Istanbul and New York both drink from reservoirs far from most of the people they serve. Istanbul, a city of more than 15 million people, draws much of its water from reservoirs in the forested basins around the city. New York supplies about nine million people largely from its Catskill and Delaware systems, much of it from more than a hundred miles away. Both cities protect that land through law, but they use very different instruments, and the authority each holds over its watersheds is not the same.
To compare them, I use two terms. Reach is whether a protection instrument can bind the decisions that shape land in the watershed. A trigger is a written requirement that a specified monitoring result sets a review or a change in motion. The useful question for a utility is not which city protects its water better, but how each kind of binding instrument can be changed when monitoring shows something new.
Istanbul: Binding Through The Plan Hierarchy
Istanbul's drinking water basins are protected by basin protection plans, prepared under a national regulation on drinking water basins and issued by the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry or by the city's water utility, İSKİ. Under the adopted plan for the Alibey reservoir, for example, new development plans, amendments, and revisions at every scale must comply with the basin plan, and the water administration's opinion is required while those plans are prepared. The adopted plan for the Elmalı reservoirs can compel changes to existing land use through plan revision. Through the plan hierarchy, the basin plans reach plan-making and plan revision across the basin.
What I did not find in the adopted texts I examined is a provision that requires a plan to be reviewed when specified monitoring results change. Revision follows a timetable and assigns tasks to agencies. That does not show that findings are ignored in practice. It shows that no written rule makes them the reason for a review.
New York: Binding Through Rules, Property And A Performance Test
New York's upstate watershed binds land in other ways. The city does not control zoning in the towns where its reservoirs sit. Under the 1997 New York City Watershed Memorandum of Agreement, signed by the city, the state, the U.S. EPA, watershed counties and towns, and environmental organizations, it relies instead on three kinds of instruments. Its watershed regulations require project review and approval for specified activities, from septic and wastewater systems to impervious surfaces and structures near streams and larger land clearing near watercourses and reservoirs. Its fee-simple land acquisition program, which buys open land from willing sellers at fair market value, had acquired more than 97,000 acres by 2020. And partnership programs fund local measures.
Above these instruments sits a recurring performance test. Because the Catskill and Delaware supplies are not filtered, the city must hold a filtration avoidance determination from its regulators. The determination is reviewed and renewed periodically and depends on the city showing that its watershed protection program works. If it does not, the city faces filtration, at a cost estimated in 2010 at well over $10 billion. Evidence about the watershed therefore has a formal route into decisions about the protection program itself.
Such a test can change obligations when the evidence changes. Portland, Oregon, also drew unfiltered water from a protected watershed. In January 2017 it began detecting low levels of Cryptosporidium in its Bull Run supply that exceeded what federal drinking water rules allow. The state revoked the city's treatment variance in 2018, and the city must now treat its water. The City Council chose filtration from among the treatment options, and the facility is required to be in operation by 2029. The regulator required treatment; the choice of filtration was the city's.
What The Comparison Suggests
Istanbul binds plan-making through the plan hierarchy. New York binds specific activities and land through regulation, ownership, and a performance test. For monitoring, the question that matters is the same in both: which written process obliges these instruments, and the planning decisions around them, to change when the data change? In the Istanbul basin plans I examined, there is no such monitoring trigger. In New York, the performance test works as a trigger for the protection program as a whole; how its findings travel into individual regulatory thresholds or into local plans is a separate question, and one each utility can check for itself.
Each system suggests something to the other. A basin plan in Istanbul could name a small set of monitoring indicators and require an early review when any of them crosses a threshold, so that revision follows the evidence and not the calendar alone. For American systems that protect source water through regulation and acquisition, Istanbul shows a further route: where state law allows it, watershed protection standards could become a formal reference point for local comprehensive plans in source-water basins.
Three Checks For Source-Water Utilities
Utilities can test their own arrangements without waiting for new legislation, as long as they keep apart what they can decide alone and what depends on others.
First, write down what would reopen your program. List the monitoring results that, if they changed, should prompt a review of acquisition priorities, regulatory thresholds, or partner programs. If the honest answer is "the next scheduled review," the program has no explicit monitoring-based trigger. A utility can usually adopt internal indicators, thresholds, and a named office to respond on its own authority. Making them binding on other agencies is a separate question.
Second, map where your instruments reach. Overlay the areas covered by your regulations, easements, and owned land on the zoning and comprehensive plan designations in the watershed. The gaps show where protection depends on voluntary cooperation, and where a single land-use decision could undo years of investment.
Third, find your formal seat in local planning. Check whether state law or local procedure gives the utility a right to be notified of, or to comment on, plan amendments and rezonings in the watershed, or a role in environmental review. Where it does, use it consistently and keep a record of the comments. Where it does not, a notification agreement with counties and towns is possible, but it depends on their willingness to take part.
None of these steps replaces the legal reforms a system may eventually need. But together they show a utility which of its protections can respond to new evidence, and which cannot yet.
Özge Çelik Yılmaz, PhD, is an urban planner who studies the legal and institutional conditions under which environmental evidence reaches planning decisions. She works at the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality and a TÜBİTAK postdoctoral researcher at Bursa Uludağ University, on watershed governance in Istanbul. She writes in a personal capacity. The provision-level scoring of Istanbul and New York City on which this piece draws is openly available at doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21649244.